By Alexander Chanthunya
#AppealsExplained #CourtTerminology #LegalBasics #DismissedInPart #DeniedInPart
Legal language can be intimidating, especially when you’re reading through a court decision. If you’ve ever come across a ruling that says an appeal was “dismissed in part and denied in part,” you’re not alone in wondering what that actually means.
In this guide, we break it down in simple language. We’ll explore what these phrases mean, why courts use them, and what they mean for your case. Whether you’re a litigant, law student, or just someone curious about legal terms, this article will help you make sense of it.
What Does “Dismissed in Part” Mean?
When a court dismisses part of an appeal, it means the judges refused to consider that part. They didn’t say whether it was right or wrong, they simply didn’t review it at all.
Common Reasons for Dismissal:
- Lack of jurisdiction: The court doesn’t have the authority to review that issue.
- Mootness: The issue no longer matters (for example, because of a settlement or change in circumstances).
- Procedural errors: The appellant missed deadlines or failed to follow court rules.
- Unappealable orders: Some orders can’t be appealed until the full case is resolved.
Example:
If you bring up an issue on appeal that wasn’t argued in the trial court, the appellate court may dismiss that part for not being properly raised.
What Does “Denied in Part” Mean?
When a court denies part of an appeal, it means it did consider the issue, looked at the evidence and the law and found no reason to change the lower court’s ruling.
The denial shows that the judges read your arguments, reviewed the record, and applied legal principles, but they just didn’t agree.
Example:
If you appeal based on three different legal arguments, and the court finds two of them unpersuasive, it will “deny in part” based on those.
🆚 Dismissed vs. Denied: What’s the Difference?
| Feature | Dismissed in Part | Denied in Part |
| Reviewed on merits? | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Reason | Procedural or jurisdictional | Substantive (based on law) |
| Outcome | Not considered at all | Considered and rejected |
| Legal analysis? | No | Yes |
Why Courts Use Both Terms
Appeals often involve several claims. Some may be:
- Improperly raised → dismissed
- Properly raised but legally weak → denied
Using both “dismissed in part” and “denied in part” makes clear what the court reviewed and what it didn’t. This gives the public, the parties, and future courts a detailed record of how the decision was reached.
Common Reasons for Dismissal
Let’s go deeper into why courts dismiss part of an appeal:
1. Lack of Jurisdiction
Courts only hear cases they’re authorized to decide. If an issue falls outside that scope, it’s dismissed.
2. Late Filing
Most courts have strict deadlines (see Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure Rule 4). Missing them may lead to dismissal.
3. Issue Not Preserved
Courts generally won’t hear arguments raised for the first time on appeal. This is known as the preservation requirement.
4. Mootness
If the dispute has already been resolved, the court may find the issue irrelevant and dismiss it.
Common Reasons for Denial
Denial doesn’t mean your issue was ignored, it just didn’t hold up legally.
1. No Legal Error Found
If the trial court followed the law, the appellate court will likely affirm the decision.
2. Not Enough Evidence
Appellate courts rarely re-weigh evidence. If the trial court’s ruling was reasonable, the appeal fails.
3. Harmless Error
Even if the trial court made a mistake, it may not matter. Courts follow the “harmless error” rule, from Chapman v. California, 386 U.S. 18 (1967).
Real-Life Case Examples
Case 1: United States v. Zubaydah, 595 U.S. ___ (2022)
Parts of the appeal were dismissed under the state secrets doctrine, others denied after legal review.
Case 2: Jennings v. Rodriguez, 583 U.S. ___ (2018)
The Supreme Court dismissed claims improperly brought under immigration statutes and denied others on the merits.
Find full texts at:
- SupremeCourt.gov
- Law.Cornell.edu
Strategy Tips for Filing Appeals
If you’re appealing a decision:
- ✅ Be selective: Don’t raise every argument focus on your strongest ones.
- ✅ Preserve issues early: Raise objections during the trial or you risk dismissal later.
- ✅ Meet deadlines: Always file on time.
- ✅ Cite authority: Support every claim with statutes or cases that the court recognizes.
Procedural Limits You Should Know
Many dismissals come from failing to meet basic rules, including:
- Standing: Only those directly affected can appeal.
- Final Judgment Rule: In most cases, only final orders can be appealed.
- Ripeness: The issue must be fully developed—not hypothetical.
Refer to:
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1) – subject-matter jurisdiction
- Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure Rule 3 & 4 – notices and deadlines
Final Thoughts: Why These Terms Matter
Understanding these phrases is more than legal jargon—it’s about knowing where your case stands.
- A dismissed issue could potentially be fixed and refiled.
- A denied issue usually marks the end of the road, unless a higher court decides to review it.
The next time you see “dismissed in part and denied in part” in a court decision, you’ll know exactly what it means—and why it matters.
If you’re unsure about how your appeal was handled, ask your lawyer or read the full court opinion. Many are available online through public databases like:
- Justia.com
- Google Scholar
- CourtListener.com
#UnderstandingAppeals #DismissedVsDenied #LegalEducation #AppealRulingsExplained
#CourtTermsSimplified #AlexanderChanthunya #LawForEveryone #AppealsProcess #LegalHelp #USCourts
Site Title 